Bulgaria’s Judiciary Give Thumbs down to New Judicial Map

All opinions received so far at the Bulgarian Justice Ministry in connection with a reform of the judicial map proposed by the Supreme Judicial Council (SJC) are negative, the Ministry said on Monday during a discussion it organized on accessible and effective justice.

The radical reform in question, known as Version 4, envisages the closure of a large number of small regional courts countrywide (113 altogether) and their conversion into territorial divisions of the nearest larger courts. The types of cases under the jurisdiction of regional courts will be reduced. District courts will examine cases at the first instance, and appellate courts at the second instance. Part of the judges will be transferred to higher courts. Territorial divisions may try cases by video conference, or a judge will sit on site. The idea is to cut costs, but litigants may have to invest a lot more time and money to appear before a faraway court.

Caretaker Justice Minister Yanaki Stoilov said that "the lower a court, the more significant social role it plays" and that the
reform version "gives rise to more questions than it solves".

Deputy Justice Minister Maria Pavlova said that opinions from municipal councils and mayors of dozens of settlements, from the
 Supreme Bar Council of Bulgaria and the Notary Chamber have been sent and continue to arrive at the Ministry. More than 500
judges have signed an objection to the proposed reform and have sent it to the SJC.

Silvia Georgieva of the National Association of Municipalities argued that local communities, too, should be consulted about the judicial map reform. She said that this discussion is part of the debate about the depopulation and development of the
regions which engaged...